Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Presuppositions and idealizations...


Lars Syll quotes an interesting passage from Hans Albert on the weird use of theoretical abstraction in economics; "weird" as in very unusual and rather questionable from the perspective of the rest of science. As Albert writes,

Clearly, it is possible to interpret the ‘presuppositions’ of a theoretical system … not as hypotheses, but simply as limitations to the area of application of the system in question. Since a relationship to reality is usually ensured by the language used in economic statements, in this case the impression is generated that a content-laden statement about reality is being made, although the system is fully immunized and thus without content. In my view that is often a source of self-deception in pure economic thought …

A further possibility for immunizing theories consists in simply leaving open the area of application of the constructed model so that it is impossible to refute it with counter examples. This of course is usually done without a complete knowledge of the fatal consequences of such methodological strategies for the usefulness of the theoretical conception in question, but with the view that this is a characteristic of especially highly developed economic procedures: the thinking in models, which, however, among those theoreticians who cultivate neoclassical thought, in essence amounts to a new form of Platonism.

In other words, economists (many of them) start with some assumptions or presuppositions, derive some conclusions, and then feel as if they've made a real and lasting contribution to understanding the world. They've produced an "if... then" statement; established a logical connection. It's often a secondary consideration whether this "if...then" has anything at all to teach us about OUR world. Economics, in this sense, is just a branch of mathematics. Pure mathematics, not applied mathematics.

This is interesting as it resonates quite strongly with the conclusions of the recent work of Itzhak Gilboa and colleagues, who try to understand how economists see economics in relation to the rest of science. Their conclusion is much the same -- that many if not most economists (theorists, at least) see their task as producing "theoretical cases," which cannot possibly be refuted, as they are merely logical connections between antecedent suppositions and logical implications.

I wrote about the article in a recent Bloomberg column, the beginning of which goes below:

When economists say they can "explain" something, beware: Their understanding of the word might be very different from yours.

Several years ago, in the immediate wake of the financial crisis, economist Ricardo Caballero wrote about what he called the “pretense-of-knowledge syndrome” in academia. Economists, he argued, had become “so mesmerized” with the internal logic of their theories that much of the discipline -- even that part concerned directly with policy making -- had spiraled off into fantasy. Even when they studied issues close to the crisis, such as bubbles, panics and fire sales, they relegated them to the periphery of macroeconomics, which at its core valued mathematical elegance over usefulness.

Not much has changed since then. That, at least, is the conclusion of Itzhak Gilboa and a group of economists who recently tried to understand why their profession operates so differently from most sciences. Academic economists, they say, use the term "explanation" in a way that other scientists never would. Instead of developing realistic and testable theories like those in biology or physics, they often aim only to develop "theoretical cases" -- imaginary mathematical worlds with their own rules of cause and effect.

Suppose, for example, that an economist wants to explain a persistent recession following a financial crisis....  

Read more here.
 

40 comments:

  1. It is not a secret that economists have a big influence on simple people. Their opinions are important for them. It seems to me that economists have to give us more realistic worldview. Everyone knows that it is very difficult financial situation in the USA. Many people take financial help. As for me, I often turn to online money service where I take easy money loan online 24/7. It always helps me to be sure in my financial future and to solve my financial problems with the help of these loans.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Idealize says to represent in an ideal form or character, I have read the post and it's so clear , Foreign Exchange.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I hear however does one have to be kicked out of physics in order to have interest for societal issues such as economics or finance? It actually sounds like most people with a quantitative background can never be interested in social/economic sciences, and I find it hard to be true. bookkeeping tampa

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is more interesting one. I like this post. The article is containing the more ideas and interesting content. The writing company of Essay writing service reviews is providing the all types of essay papers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Definitely, it can be done to translate the ‘presuppositions’ of any theoretical system much less hypotheses, but purely as limitations to the area connected with application in the system involved. Since a new relationship to the truth is usually ensured because of the language used in economic phrases, in that case the actual impression is actually generated that the content-laden affirmation about the truth is being made, although the system is totally immunized and therefore without information. In the view that is generally a source connected with self-deception within pure fiscal thought.

    Buy cheap essay online

    ReplyDelete
  6. stock market investment tips, share market calls.
    Share market Calls is a best stock market Firm in India. Share Market Calls provide 2 days free trail tips in all stock market services. Equity tips, Stock Cash tips, Forex tips, Option tips, Index tips, Commodity tips, MCX tips, Bullion tips, Gold Tips, Silver tips, Forex Tips.
    Share Market Calls provide 85% accuracy tips.
    Visit: www.sharemarketcalls.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Paraphrasing is not complicated thing but it just need time and practice. If you canot write well grammar you can simply use rewording sentences generator that will give outstanding look to your essay or document.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Writing is important. What we are going to write is not a matter, how we are representing it is the the relevant one. One incident can review 20 types by 20 people. That is the difference.
    Custom essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  9. Option Tips wow Nice blog .. i read the article fully .. so nice content ,, keep posting such type of ideas to gain knowledge

    ReplyDelete
  10. With a large number of English speaking writers, Perfect Essays Online is able to offer paper writing in virtually every topic field and at any level of study! All of our writers have the highest degree level and perform paper works only in content areas and at academic levels for which they are qualified.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Well! Writing is important for all over us. So we should correct a sentence with power of grammar. We have aware of their power.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for your information! Custom term papers is professional writing service that always satisfied their customers.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Indeed, that it really a weird use of theretical abstraction in economics. If you do not want to have your college paper questionable or rewritten many times, Click here to visit this page

    ReplyDelete
  14. This blog is very informative and all the content about the market given here are useful. Epic Research also provides this type of significant data.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very nice post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog and wished to mention that I've truly enjoyed browsing your weblog posts.Drug Card

    ReplyDelete
  16. The Usa offers a lot of choices which choosing it's possible to be difficult! Narrow lower your best choices as well as let your whole family choose.standing desk mat

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you very much for your post! Feel free to visit my website! the best free online games for you! funny game wormax.io, game wheely 8 | Games for kids at zoxy games | kizi games Much fun!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thank you for sharing such a informative post with us, it will beneficial for everyone, It is one of the best sites that I have visited. I am looking forward to read more blogs post from here
    make my assignment

    ReplyDelete
  19. JKBOSE 10th Class Result 2018, Jammu 10th Annual Exam Result 2018 : On May 2018 Jammu and Kashmir board is displayed the 10th Annual Exam Result 2018.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi Admin,

    I'm following your blog regulerly. Your all post are really nice.. Thanks for sharing. Please keep it up.

    Thanks.
    CFA course

    ReplyDelete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks for sharing, nice post! Post really provice useful information!

    FadoExpress chuyên dịch vụ chuyển phát nhanh siêu tốc đi khắp thế giới, nổi bật là dịch vụ gửi hàng đi mỹ, gửi hàng đi úc uy tín, giá rẻ.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Đón xe không phải là phương thức vận chuyển tốt nhất, vì giao thông rất đông. Để đi từ hai sân bay chính - LaGuardia (LGA) và John F. Kennedy International (JFK) - vào thành phố, bạn có thể muốn đi taxi hoặc giá vé máy bay đi Mỹ 1 chiều dịch vụ đi xe như Lyft hoặc Uber. Nếu bạn muốn kết hợp tham quan một chút với phương tiện di chuyển của mình, hãy xem xét một chuyến tham quan bằng xe buýt hoặc tham quan bằng thuyền .

    Nhiều khách du lịch Bờ Đông có xu hướng đến Thành phố New York trên một trong những dịch vụ xe buýt như BoltBus hoặc Megabus vé máy bay đi Mỹ hạng thương gia . Amtrak là một cách phổ biến khác để vào thành phố và xe lửa lăn vào ga Penn hàng ngày.

    ReplyDelete
  24. The review you shared is outstanding . The clarity in your content is simply excellent and i can assume you’re an expert.. Thanks a lot and please carry on the rewarding work.
    Advisors

    ReplyDelete
  25. 스포츠토토 For the reason that the admin of this website is working, no
    doubt very shortly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.


    ReplyDelete
  26. 토토 Ahaa, its good discussion about this post here at this webpage, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting
    here.

    ReplyDelete
  27. If some one wishes expert view regarding running a blog afterward i recommend
    him/her to go to see this web site, Keep up the nice work. 토토사이트


    ReplyDelete
  28. Thank you so much for writing such interesting content. Drafting content may require a lot of dedication. So if you are facing issues while composing your engineering assignment. Do connect with experts and avail of Engineering Assignment Help in addition to submitting the assignment within the deadlines.

    ReplyDelete
  29. project management assignment help organising, inspiring, and managing resources to accomplish particular objectives within an organisation is the discipline of aid. A project is generally a venture with a clear beginning and finish that is undertaken to fulfil certain aims and objectives, usually to bring about positive improvements or additional value.

    ReplyDelete
  30. assignment samples
    is intended to provide students who are drowning in dissertation-related stress with the academic lifebelt to prevent their scores from dropping into the sea of failures. We vow to boost your dissertation scores and let you finally breathe a sigh of relief due to our exceptional services by offering online dissertation writing services in the finest way possible.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Great & Best Blog Ever. Your knowledge is amazing & thanks for Sharing. i would like to inform you if anyone wants Poland Visa From UK so visit our site Poland visa UK website. We are provide all type of visas for UK Residents. poland visa appointment

    ReplyDelete